It’s not exactly a comforting sight to watch a man dissolving the bones of his victims in vats of acid, so unsurprisingly this scene turned out to be the moment that turned our readers’ stomachs. This scene landed 21.49% of our readers’ votes.
Our fans aren’t keen on acts of violence against animals either – even if they’re already dead when they encounter this fictionalized version of Jeffrey Dahmer’s story. The series’ pig dissection scene takes place in Episode 2, “Please Don’t Go”. It shows the teenage version of the serial killer developing an affinity for the dissection techniques he will use on his future victims. His fascination with dead animals took second place with 19.50% of the vote.
During the seventh episode of the series, “Cassandra,” Glenda recalls that at some point during their most recent confrontation, Dahmer served her a sandwich that had meat in it, and she wasn’t entirely sure if it wasn’t human flesh. The scene aroused 17.02% of our viewers’ twitches.