Another of the original Dead by Daylight villains made it into Hooked on You: The Wraith. The Wraith goes by many names, including Philip, Banshee, and Bob, and his character description makes him sound as endearing as he is terrifying. He may not look like it, but underneath this wiry man is a “quiet, inquisitive, sensitive boy.”
He’s also a bit odd and will appreciate any weirdness you bring to the conversation. His villain backstory isn’t exactly the pinnacle of villainy either. He just wanted to save someone and got caught in the crossfire.
Considering some of the high-pitched stakes in romanticizing The Trapper or The Huntress, The Wraith sounds like a much safer option. However, he’s a villain for good reason, so despite his great looks and personality, don’t fall near him. Finally, his invisibility could play a role and cause trouble in the new sim.